Natural Cream Eyeliner

Blend, smudge, or sharpen. Natural cream eyeliner gives eyes rich color payoff with room to play, in clean formulas that hold everyday lines and softly dramatic finishes without irritating the eye.

Skip to results list

Filters

Translation missing: en.content.item_count

Filter

  • Precision Colour Pencil - Makeup - 19/99 Beauty - PCP001-1 - The Detox Market | Voros - a signature shade of red with a slight blue undertone which works on all skin tones
    Precision Colour Pencil - Makeup - 19/99 Beauty - PCP001-2 - The Detox Market | Voros - a signature shade of red with a slight blue undertone which works on all skin tones
    New New Shades
    19/99 Beauty
    Precision Colour Lip Pencil
    $18.20 $26.00
  • Precision Colour Pencil
    Precision Colour Pencil - Makeup - 19/99 Beauty - PCP005-3 - The Detox Market | Wasser - a cool water blue shade that is slightly lighter than a classic cobalt blue
    New New Shades
    19/99 Beauty
    Precision Colour Eye Pencil
    $26.00
  • Ere Perez-Jojoba Eye Pencil-Makeup-ErePerez-JojobaEyePencil-Cerulean-SQ-20002-no-The Detox Market |
    Ere Perez-Jojoba Eye Pencil-Makeup-ErePerez-JojobaEyePencil-Cerulean-SQ-2000-The Detox Market | Cerulean
    best seller New Shades
    Ere Perez
    Jojoba Eye Pencil
    $24.00
  • Straight Line Kohl Eye Pencil
    Straight Line Kohl Eye Pencil - Makeup - RMS Beauty - RMS_EP1_STRAIGHT_LINE_KOHL_EYE_PENCIL_816248024995_QUAD - The Detox Market | Black
    New Shades
    RMS Beauty
    Straight Line Kohl Eye Pencil
    $27.00
  • Satin Kohl Eye Pencil
    Satin Kohl Eye Pencil
    SWEED
    Satin Kohl Eye Pencil
    $25.00
  • Vegan Eye Liner - Makeup - Fitglow Beauty - BBeige_box_web - The Detox Market | Brightening Beige
    Vegan Eye Liner - Makeup - Fitglow Beauty - BBeige_02 - The Detox Market | Brightening Beige
    Fitglow Beauty
    Vegan Eye Liner
    $24.00
  • Satin Eyeliner
    Satin Eyeliner
    SWEED
    Satin Eyeliner
    $26.00
  • KANARI Precision Colour Pencil - Limited Edition
    KANARI Precision Colour Pencil - Limited Edition - Makeup - 19/99 Beauty - PCP014-2 - The Detox Market |
    19/99 Beauty
    KANARI Precision Colour Pencil - Limited Edition
    $18.20 $26.00

Cream Eyeliner for Smooth Definition

A softer line brings quiet depth to the eyes while still feeling polished. Natural cream eyeliner gives you the glide and control needed to shape the lash line, smudge for a smoky effect, or build a more defined look. And clean creamy textures move easily across the lid before setting into place, with finishes that range from subtle daytime definition to richer evening looks.

Shop skincare from brands that meet our high standards

SWEED
SWEED
Necessaire
Necessaire
Osea
Osea
Dedcool
Dedcool
True Botanicals
True Botanicals
Manucurist
Manucurist
View all brands

Shop in-store with expert advice.

We're committed to what's best for the planet, and for you.

Our Standards + Commitments